Managed Retreat Made SIMPLE: 7 Important Facts and Examples

Managed retreat is a coastal management strategy in which the coastline is deliberately allowed to move inland in a planned and controlled way, rather than being held in place by sea walls and other defences. Often called managed realignment, it usually involves breaching or removing old defences so that low-lying land floods and becomes salt marsh or mudflat. Managed retreat is a key part of Topic 2:

Before and after diagram of managed retreat, showing a breached sea wall, new salt marsh and a new embankment inland
How managed retreat replaces an old sea wall with salt marsh and a new defence inland.

What is managed retreat?

For much of the twentieth century, the main response to coastal erosion and flooding in the UK was to build hard defences such as sea walls. Managed retreat takes a different approach. Instead of fighting the sea everywhere, it accepts that some land will be lost and plans for this in a way that reduces risk to people and creates benefits for the environment.

There are two main forms of this approach:

  • Managed realignment of defences – old sea walls or embankments are breached or removed, and a new line of defence is built further inland. The land in between is allowed to flood and develop into intertidal habitat.
  • Relocation of people and property – where erosion cannot be stopped, communities are helped to move away from the coast, sometimes with compensation or support to rebuild elsewhere.

Key terms to learn

TermDefinition
Managed realignmentAllowing the shoreline to move inland in a controlled way, usually to a new line of defence
Shoreline Management Plan (SMP)A long-term plan that sets the management policy for each stretch of coast
Salt marshA vegetated area of mud and silt flooded by the tide, which absorbs wave energy
Intertidal zoneThe area between high and low tide
Coastal squeezeThe loss of intertidal habitat trapped between rising sea levels and fixed defences
Hold the lineMaintaining the existing position of the coastline with defences

Fact 1: Managed retreat is one of four shoreline management options

In England and Wales, the coastline is divided into sections, and each section is given a policy in a Shoreline Management Plan (SMP). There are four policy options:

  1. Hold the line – keep the shoreline where it is, using hard or soft engineering.
  2. Advance the line – build new defences seaward of the existing line.
  3. Managed realignment – allow the shoreline to move, with management to control the process.
  4. No active intervention – do not invest in defences and allow natural processes to take place.

Managed retreat is chosen where the cost of holding the line is greater than the value of the land being protected, or where it brings significant environmental benefits. The guide to coastal management strategies compares all of these approaches.

Fact 2: It works with natural processes

The key idea behind managed retreat is that natural landforms can protect the coast better than concrete. When an old sea wall is breached, the tide floods the land behind it. Over time, mud and silt are deposited, plants colonise the mud and a salt marsh develops.

Salt marshes and mudflats absorb wave energy and reduce the height of waves before they reach the new defences. This means the new embankment inland can be smaller and cheaper than a sea wall built directly on the open coast. The process of building up a salt marsh is similar to that found behind spits and in sheltered estuaries.

Fact 3: It is often cheaper in the long term

Hard engineering is expensive to build and maintain. Sea walls can cost thousands of pounds per metre and must be repaired or replaced as they are damaged by storms. As sea levels rise, defences need to be made higher and stronger, increasing costs further.

Realignment usually has high initial costs, for example for buying land and building new embankments, but much lower maintenance costs. Over several decades, it can therefore be more cost-effective than holding the line, particularly where the land being protected is low-value farmland. The guide to hard engineering explains the costs and benefits of traditional defences.

Fact 4: It creates valuable wildlife habitats

Salt marshes and mudflats are among the most productive habitats on Earth. They provide feeding grounds for wading birds and wildfowl, nursery areas for fish and habitats for many specialist plants and invertebrates.

Many of these habitats have been lost as a result of land reclamation and coastal squeeze, where rising sea levels push habitats against fixed defences. Managed retreat helps to replace these lost habitats. Salt marshes also store carbon in their soils, so new marshes can make a small contribution to tackling climate change.

Fact 5: It involves difficult decisions

Managed retreat is often controversial because it involves giving up land. The main disadvantages are:

  • Loss of farmland – productive agricultural land is flooded and can no longer be farmed.
  • Loss of homes and businesses – where whole communities are affected, people may lose their homes and livelihoods.
  • Compensation – landowners do not always receive compensation, which can lead to strong opposition.
  • Uncertainty – falling property values and difficulty obtaining insurance or mortgages in areas where defences will not be maintained.
  • Changes to heritage and landscape – historic buildings, footpaths and familiar views may be lost.

Because of these issues, any realignment scheme requires careful consultation with local people, landowners and organisations such as the Environment Agency and conservation groups.

Fact 6: Sea level rise is making managed retreat more important

Global sea levels are rising because of climate change, as warming causes seawater to expand and land ice to melt, and the IPCC reports that they will continue to rise throughout this century. In parts of south-east England, the land is also slowly sinking, which adds to the relative rise in sea level. The guide to isostatic and eustatic sea level change explains these processes.

As sea levels rise, it will become more expensive and difficult to hold the line everywhere. Managed retreat is therefore expected to play a larger role in future coastal management, both in the UK and around the world.

Managed retreat around the world

The approach is not limited to the UK. In the Netherlands, the “Room for the River” programme moved some river dykes further back to give rivers more space to flood safely. In the USA, some low-lying coastal communities, such as Isle de Jean Charles in Louisiana, have received government support to relocate away from land that is being lost to the sea.

These international examples show that the same principle can be applied to both coasts and rivers. In each case, giving water more space is seen as a safer and more sustainable long-term solution than building ever-higher defences.

Fact 7: Managed retreat has been used successfully in the UK

Several realignment schemes have been completed around the UK coast, particularly in the low-lying estuaries of eastern and southern England.

Abbotts Hall Farm, Essex

At Abbotts Hall Farm on the Blackwater Estuary, the sea wall was deliberately breached in several places in 2002. Farmland behind the wall was flooded by the tide and has developed into salt marsh, mudflat and grassland, providing habitat for birds and fish while protecting the land behind.

Wallasea Island, Essex

At Wallasea Island, the RSPB has created a large wetland nature reserve by realigning the coast. Millions of tonnes of earth excavated during the construction of the Crossrail railway tunnels in London were used to raise the land and shape new lagoons, mudflats and salt marsh.

Fairbourne, Wales

The village of Fairbourne in Gwynedd is a well-known example of the relocation form of managed retreat. The Shoreline Management Plan for the area concluded that it would not be sustainable to defend the village indefinitely, and that a managed realignment policy should be adopted in the coming decades. This decision has caused great concern among residents and shows the social challenges of managed retreat.

Happisburgh, Norfolk

At Happisburgh, soft cliffs are retreating rapidly and the decision was taken not to replace failing defences. A local council programme helped to relocate some at-risk cliff-top properties and facilities further inland.

Case study: Medmerry managed realignment, West Sussex

Medmerry, between Selsey and Bracklesham on the West Sussex coast, is one of the best-known examples of managed retreat in the UK. Completed by the Environment Agency in 2013, it was described as the largest open-coast managed realignment scheme in Europe at the time.

Why it was needed

Before the scheme, the low-lying land at Medmerry was protected by a shingle bank that had to be constantly rebuilt after storms. It was frequently breached, flooding homes, a large holiday park, farmland and the road to Selsey. Maintaining the shingle bank was becoming increasingly expensive and unreliable.

What was done

  • New clay embankments were built inland, several kilometres in total, forming a new line of defence.
  • A breach was made in the shingle bank, allowing the sea to flood the land behind.
  • The flooded area developed into intertidal habitat, including salt marsh, mudflats and lagoons.
  • The site is managed as a nature reserve by the RSPB, with footpaths and cycle routes for visitors.

Impacts

Positive impactsNegative impacts
Reduced flood risk to hundreds of homes and to the road to SelseyLoss of farmland that was flooded to create the new habitat
Created a large area of new intertidal habitat for birds and wildlifeHigh initial construction cost
Lower long-term maintenance costs than rebuilding the shingle bankSome local concern about change to the landscape
New opportunities for tourism and recreationChanges to access along parts of the shoreline

Medmerry shows how managed retreat can provide reliable flood protection while also creating valuable habitats and recreational space. Students can use it to evaluate the success of soft engineering approaches on the coast.

Managed retreat: frequently asked questions

Is managed retreat the same as managed realignment?

Yes. The terms are often used interchangeably. Managed realignment is the official term used in UK Shoreline Management Plans.

Is managed retreat hard or soft engineering?

It is usually classed as a soft engineering approach because it works with natural processes rather than against them.

Why is managed retreat used?

It is used where defending the coast is too expensive or unsustainable, and where creating salt marsh can provide natural flood protection and new habitats.

What are the disadvantages of managed retreat?

Land is lost to the sea, landowners may not be compensated, communities may have to move and property values can fall.

What is the best UK example of managed retreat?

Medmerry in West Sussex is one of the best-known examples. Other examples include Abbotts Hall Farm and Wallasea Island in Essex.

Managed retreat: key takeaways

  • Managed retreat allows the coastline to move inland in a controlled way.
  • It is also known as managed realignment and is one of four Shoreline Management Plan options.
  • Breaching old defences allows salt marsh to form, which absorbs wave energy.
  • It is often cheaper than hard engineering in the long term.
  • It creates valuable habitats and helps to reduce coastal squeeze.
  • Disadvantages include loss of farmland, homes and property value.
  • Sea level rise is making this approach increasingly important.
  • Medmerry in West Sussex is a key UK case study.

To conclude

Managed retreat represents a shift in thinking from fighting the sea to working with natural processes. It can provide cost-effective flood protection and valuable habitats, but it involves difficult decisions about which land to give up.

Using examples such as Medmerry, students can evaluate when managed retreat is the most sustainable option. The Environment Agency leads many of these schemes in England.

Dr Hayley Stainton

About the author

Dr Hayley Stainton is an educator, examiner and the founder of The Geography Teacher. She has a PhD and more than 20 years’ experience teaching at school and university level. Read more about Hayley